The Strad's experts evaluate the latest string recordings
Dvořák: Cello Concerto in B minor op.104, The Water Goblin op.107, In Nature’s Realm op.91
A warm-hearted solo interpretation let down by its orchestral accompaniment
Sunday, 26 May 2013
Zuill Bailey (cello) Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra/Jun Märkl
Telarc TEL 32927-02
This latest release of Dvořák’s ever-popular Cello Concerto, recorded live in February 2011, boasts a fine rendition of the cello part, but the contribution from the Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra, which provides sophisticated playing for the two tone poems that fill out the disc, is considerably far from sparkling. The rather boomy recording does little to help either.
Nevertheless Zuill Bailey appears undeterred, bringing impressive warmth to the second subject of the first movement despite the glutinous bass-line, and eloquence to the nostalgic transformation of the opening idea at the Molto sostenuto. But there is little feeling of chamber-music dialogue from the orchestra in the flute and oboe solos and the woodwind generally presents a nasal concoction for the start of the second movement – here Bailey follows with nicely judged rubato that is expressive but never mannered. After a feisty and forthright opening to the finale, he serves a heady cocktail of swerving lyricism and commanding virtuosity, with some particularly eloquent playing at the close.
From the June 2012 issue. Subscribe to The Strad or download our digital edition as part of a 30-day free trial.