The Strad's experts evaluate the latest string recordings
Grundman: A mortuis resurgere (The Resurrection of Christ)
Neither work nor performance make a convincing case for themselves
Monday, 25 August 2014
Brodsky Quartet, Susana Cordón (soprano)
Chandos CHAN CHSA 5138
A little of Jorge Grundman’s The Resurrection of Christ goes a long way, at least on this disc. Based on St John’s Gospel, it is a chamber oratorio for soprano and string quartet designed as a companion piece to Haydn’s Seven Last Words – picking up from the Crucifixion and leading to the Resurrection.
Grundman’s background spans an early career in pop groups, studies in music, computing and sound engineering, and compositions taking in New Age electronica and music for film and TV – but his creative ethos is now simply ‘to tell stories through the music narrative’ and to do this by simple means. The means are certainly simple here: the harmonic plan is basic and repetitive, overlaid with endlessly recurring motifs and indulgent vocalises, presenting very little dramatic shape – so that the Credo and the concluding Hosanna are largely coloured with the same generic brush.
There’s little here to test the Brodsky Quartet technically, yet the players do not sound at one with the music, as if hesitant to give it the full radiance and tonal sweetness that might make it more convincing. Capable as the recorded sound is, this is a piece designed for a cathedral acoustic and setting – listening to this studio-like rendering, it’s hard to remain engaged for long.
From the September 2014 issue. Subscribe to The Strad or download our digital edition as part of a 30-day free trial.